One line above the register's table, and a marker on the Cash balance column header, states how far the account's starting point can be trusted, in three states that are never inferred from the mere absence of a warning:
- Recorded starting point: an opening cash row exists, or the account carries an explicit-zero tracking boundary. Nothing is shown above the table, and balances are shown plainly. An account started from a statement has its holdings and cash dated the day before tracking begins, the statement's own date: those rows are the starting point, not rows from before it.
- Starting balance unconfirmed: neither exists. An account whose history simply opens with a deposit sits here: nothing is inconsistent, and nothing is proven either. The line's Set opening cash link opens the opening-balance workflow.
- Detected inconsistency: the same opening-balance check import review already uses finds an unresolved deficit or a conflict with the account's tracking boundary. The line names the problem and its Reconcile this account link opens the Reconcile sheet. In an account started from a statement, a second opening entry for a holding or for cash the statement already lists, or any opening entry dated after the statement, is one such conflict. Earlier versions offered one, already checked, whenever you sold a position the statement listed; compare the account with your broker and delete the entry if it was never real.
A transaction you enter by hand, or one Reconcile posts, follows the same rule an import does: it can't be dated before tracking began, or on or before the date of the account's opening positions, because those already state everything the account held that day. Opening positions and opening cash themselves are bounded only by the tracking start, and may sit on the statement the account started from. The message names the date and what you can do: opening entries can be re-dated or deleted in the Transactions view, but a tracking start can't be changed in the app yet. An entry an earlier version already saved outside those dates stays as it is and can still be edited.
An inconsistency is also detected when a reconciliation adjustment, which the ledger records as one, is dated before the opening position of the same holding, or a cash adjustment before the opening cash. An earlier version's Reconcile sheet could post one there, which recorded the starting holdings and cash a second time. An adjustment to a different holding is never suspected because of it. Compare the account with your broker and delete the adjustment if it repeats them; nothing is changed for you.
Cash that dips below zero for a few days is money in transit, not a deficit. Some brokers date the money-fund sale that pays for a purchase on its settlement day, usually one to three days after the buy and sometimes up to a week, so a complete history reads short over that gap and then lands where the broker does. A dip that cash climbs back out of within 10 days never suggests opening cash, never contradicts an explicit $0 start, and never makes the account inconsistent. Neither does a dip at the very end of the history that began 10 days ago or less: the sale that settles it may not have posted when you exported the file (a Friday purchase exported on Saturday, say).
Cash that stays below zero for more than 10 days, whether the history later recovers or the dip is still open more than 10 days on, is different: no settlement takes that long, so it is money the history spent and never recorded, a missing deposit or a starting balance. Without an opening cash row it is offered as opening cash. Against an explicit $0 start it is a mismatch, and the import that brings it is refused until the history reconciles to $0.
A recorded opening cash row is never contradicted by cash dipping below zero later, however long the dip lasts. The opening row has answered the starting-point question; whether the history after it is complete is the Reconcile sheet's question, and reconciling against your broker is the check that answers it.
A broker cash checkpoint that reconciles vouches for that one checkpoint. It can never promote the whole account to Recorded, because confirming one date says nothing about the rows before it.
After switching to transaction tracking
Switching a statement-tracked account to transaction tracking writes the latest statement's cash as an opening cash row dated at that statement, even when the cash is $0. A known zero is a recorded fact, so the account starts out Recorded. An account switched before this rule has no such row when its statement showed no cash, and reads Starting balance unconfirmed until you add an opening cash entry. Nothing is filled in for it automatically.